Acoustic Guitar Buying Guide – Introduction

Hey there, guitar enthusiast!

Thanks for checking out out my Acoustic Guitar Buyer’s Guide. Whether you’re looking to buy your very first acoustic guitar or adding a tenth to your collection, I’ve created this guide to help you navigate the sometimes overwhelming world of acoustic guitars.

Over my years of playing, teaching, and collecting guitars, I’ve learned that finding the right acoustic guitar isn’t just about technical specifications – it’s about finding an instrument that resonates with you both sonically and emotionally. That said, understanding those specs can help you make a more informed decision!

In this guide, I’ll walk you through everything from body shapes to tonewoods, bracing patterns to electronics. You’ll find my personal recommendations at different price points, interactive tools to help you narrow down your choices, and practical advice for testing and maintaining your new instrument.

What You’ll Find in This Guide:

  • Different body shapes and sizes and how they affect tone and comfort
  • How top, back, and side woods influence your sound
  • Understanding construction methods and bracing patterns
  • Neck profiles, scale lengths, and playability factors
  • Electronics and amplification options
  • Budget recommendations from beginner to professional
  •  Maintenance and setup tips
  •  Common myths and misconceptions about acoustic guitars

But before we dive into all of the technical details, I want to emphasize something important: the best guitar for you is the one that makes you want to play. While understanding specifications is valuable, ultimately you should choose a guitar that feels right in your hands and sounds great to your ears. So whether you’re a detail-obsessed tonewood enthusiast or someone who just wants straightforward advice on what to buy, I’ve got you covered. Let’s find the perfect acoustic guitar for you!

If you’re just starting out and looking to get good at the acoustic guitar, checkout my video “How to get Good at Acoustic Guitar” where I share my philosophy on what makes someone good at acoustic!

Acoustic Guitar Paul Davids

Common Acoustic Guitar Myths Debunked

Alright, so you’re thinking about spending a good chunk of change on that beautiful dreadnought with the solid spruce top, convinced that the more expensive it is, the more “open” it’s going to sound in five years. Or maybe you’re thinking about polishing your fretboard with olive oil, because hey, someone on a forum swore it’ll make your rosewood sing.

We’ve all been there, deep in the acoustic guitar rabbit hole, chasing that perfect, resonant tone. But just like with electrics, the world of acoustic guitars is absolutely rife with old wives’ tales, half-truths, and straight-up misinformation that gets passed around like gospel.

So before you start humidifying your guitar in a sealed vault or agonizing over whether a slight temperature change is going to instantly destroy its tone, let’s take a deep breath. In this next section, we’re going to tackle some of the most enduring, and often frankly baffling, myths about acoustic guitars. Prepare to have some long-held beliefs gently, but firmly, strummed out of existence. Let’s dig in.

10 Acoustic Guitar Myths
Busted

Common misconceptions about buying, owning, and playing acoustic guitars — and what the reality actually is.

Whether you’re buying your first acoustic guitar or your tenth, there’s a lot of conventional wisdom out there that doesn’t hold up under scrutiny. Here are ten myths worth questioning.

01
🪵
Myth #1 Busted

“All-solid wood guitars are always better than laminate guitars.”

The Reality

While solid woods generally produce better tone and improve with age, quality laminate guitars can sound excellent. A well-built laminate guitar will often sound better than a poorly-built solid wood instrument. Additionally, laminates offer greater stability in varying environmental conditions.

02
🕰️
Myth #2 Busted

“Vintage guitars are inherently superior to modern ones.”

The Reality

While some vintage instruments are exceptional, modern manufacturing techniques have resulted in consistently high-quality guitars. The “vintage magic” is often more about the aging process and survivor bias – we only see the best vintage guitars that have survived, not the mediocre ones. Many modern builders have successfully captured vintage tones with new instruments.

03
🌳
Myth #3 Busted

“The top is the only wood that matters for tone.”

The Reality

While the top is indeed the most crucial tonal component, back and side woods, bracing, neck materials, and even binding all contribute to a guitar’s voice. It’s the interaction of all these elements that creates a guitar’s unique character.

04
💰
Myth #4 Busted

“Expensive guitars always sound better.”

The Reality

Price often correlates with quality, but there’s a point of diminishing returns, and player preference is subjective. I’ve tested budget guitars and been genuinely surprised by how good some of them sound. The value to money ratio is pretty impressive on many affordable guitars.

05
Myth #5 Busted

“Acoustic guitars sound better with age.”

The Reality

While this is generally true for solid wood guitars (as wood dries and crystallizes over time), not all guitars improve equally. The improvement comes primarily from playing the guitar regularly, which helps the top vibrate more freely. A solid wood guitar that’s never played won’t “open up” as much as one that’s played regularly.

06
🎶
Myth #6 Busted

“You need different guitars for different styles.”

The Reality

While certain body styles may excel at particular techniques, a good, versatile acoustic guitar (like an OM or Grand Auditorium) can handle most playing styles effectively. Many professional guitarists use the same instrument for various musical genres.

07
📏
Myth #7 Busted

“Higher action always means better tone.”

The Reality

While extremely low action can choke some of an acoustic guitar’s resonance, excessively high action doesn’t necessarily improve tone – it just makes the guitar harder to play. The ideal action finds the balance point where the guitar produces its best tone while remaining comfortable to play.

08
🔧
Myth #8 Busted

“You should never adjust the truss rod yourself.”

The Reality

While caution is warranted, basic truss rod adjustments are not as dangerous as often portrayed. Following proper guidelines and making small, incremental changes is generally safe. That said, if you’re uncertain, having a professional make these adjustments is always a good idea.

09
🧹
Myth #9 Busted

“Acoustic guitars don’t need regular maintenance.”

The Reality

All acoustic guitars benefit from regular maintenance, including proper humidity control, periodic cleaning, and occasional professional setups. Without proper care, even the finest instruments can develop problems that affect both playability and tone.

10
🎛️
Myth #10 Busted

“Factory setups are always perfect.”

The Reality

Even expensive guitars often benefit from a personalized setup. Factory setups are designed for average players using standard string gauges, not your specific preferences and playing style.

The best guitar is the one
you can’t stop playing.

Don’t let myths dictate your choice. Trust your ears, your hands, and your budget — and play what feels right.